Sludge Pump:
1:A - OC reduces ammo, and gives charged shot 200% velocity, so 1:B isn't needed. 1:C is still mostly useless - particularly since you aren't making a lot of puddles with this build
2:B - More fragments increases aoe, and consistency of the gun vs 2:A same damage output either way is fine. 2:C is really bad on this build.
3:B - Ammo is must due to OC, and DPS of the gun
4:B - Charge speed will around double your DPS of charged shot (1 second to .4 second charge time) the point is DPS.
5:B - Allows you to one shot slashers with single shot - helps conserve ammo. 5:A is fine as the DOT will add almost nothing while using charged shots.
OC Sludge Blast - maximum DPS option, 288 damage per charged shot. I can get 500 DPS without much difficulty
Make sure to use single shots when dealing with small/medium units. Charged shot doesn't get extra AOE like normal, it isn't great vs swarms but can be okay if you have an angle on the group. mostly use charged shot for single large targets or enemies at range.
Also you get full damage from charged shot regardless of remaining ammo - try to always use charged shot if you are under 5 ammo.
This build certainly shines on Extermination missions, but it is very viable outside them as well.
Colette wave cooker:
1:B - due to OC you will need more ammo 1:A is nearly useless. 1:C is good, but I find Wide lense is sufficient.
2:B - Fire rate helps you apply Radiation faster, the other two options really don't benefit the build at all since you shouldn't be DPSing with this gun.
3:A - Only option that does anything
4:A - Wide lens helps spread radiation quickly across large groups. 4:B reduces AOE which is detrimental to this OC. Wide lens should pretty much always be on.
5:B - Only option Giving you what you want - aoe/wave clear. T5:A is mostly fixed and is giving extra damage. Neuro at 10% is still... pretty meh, and 1.3x damage while noticable doesn't make it a great weapon. It is at least worth considering now.
T5:A damage increase works with Neuro and puddles, but not on hit corrosion DOT.
Only try to proc on enemies nearly dead from DOT (Sludge or Radiation) or on Jellies/swarmers.
OC - Gamma Contamination chance to apply radiation on the primary target, does half damage to all surrounding enemies. 154 primary damage will kill gunts and nearly kill Slashers. Scan across groups to apply to large numbers quicky, and you will destroy almost everything. Clean up remaining enemies with single shot of Sludge.
Items:
Ammo on Satchels for more trash clear - you don't need more large enemy damage.
Barbed drills don't benefit this build much, prefer speed. Either option is fine.
Axes - Mixed feelings. I pretty much only use this build on Dread hunts, and axes are the best option for those. Leaving Axes as recommended soley because I use this build exclusively for Extermination.
HE grenades - very strong option now, particularly vs mactera now that you can cook the grenades.
Neuro - Aoe to cover for our lack of wave clear, not the best.
Ripper - 145 EXPLOSIVE non radial damage. This grenade can't hit WP's, won't deal extra damage to frozen enemies and is very bad vs oppressors. It has poor Aoe, bad single target damage, does 112 Friendly fire damage. Only good for memeing on ally dwarves, or safety tunnels.
RANT
Hardened drills do NOT waste ammo. They do break terrain faster then your walking speed while using drills. If you pause every 7~ breaks and run forward, you can continue drilling without issue. They do still give you a speed boost, albeit more minor then the numbers would indicate.
There are also ways you can get around this. Ledge grab while drilling up, you can start drilling mid animation, and you won't be using walking speed.
Drilling at down angles can also give you increased move speed
Increased terrain breaks also greatly helps with saving yourself from falls by drilling into the closest wall/ledge grabbing. If you are client/high ping, it can be nearly impossible to do this without hardened drills.