Sludge Pump:
1:A - Ammo is the strongest choice here, and is just generally good. 1:B is largely overkill with the overclock we already have. 1C Extra puddle size is almost non existent, and your puddle coverage is already great due to your OC, and 25% increase is meaningless in most cases even withought this OC.
2:A - AG mixture reduces fragment spread on charged shot, for this reason extra fragments from 2:B very rarely helps. 2:C doesn't give enough damage to hit any break points on units, so A makes the most sense.
Single shots should be used to slow and apply DOT, not DPS/spam on single targets in almost all cases.
3:B - 3:A doesn't really give you any good breakpoints for anything. Might as well get more ammo, so you can abuse charged shot for AOE and burst damage.
4:B - Already an ammo efficient build, faster charged shot gives you way too much utility for the very slight ammo saved.
Also charged shot always gives max value regardless of ammo remaining in your mag. 1 ammo charged shots are just as good as 5 ammo charged. With 40 round mags 4:A does make more sense.
5:B - We have a ton of range and ammo, allowing us to spread DOT damage with impunity, and let enemies melt before ever getting in range. 5:A is also a stong option and what I had been running for a long time, but found other better options for slow- specially due to low puddle coverage per charged shot.
OC - AG mixture The entire build revolves around the fact we can get velocity on our Pump, without sacrificing puddle saturation on charged shot. It actually reduces fragment spread so even with base fragments you get complete coverage in a small area - very well controlled.
Colette Wave Cooker:
1:B - The OC reduces ammo, this is the only real option here. T1:C Wide agle is FINE but you run out of ammo fast. T1:A Damage is pointless, most of that comes from Radiation.
2:B - This helps apply radiation faster to large groups, A and B are for prolonged shots which isn't what this OC is about.
3:A - No other option here
4:A/B - No other option - reducing lens is a significant detrement to this OC (we want to hit more bugs not less)
5:A - This mod has been Mostly** fixed totally, and will do extra damage vs enemies that have goo on them. With the overclock you have incredibly range on Sludge pump making it easy to apply the Neuro. This neuro does stack with the Grenade both damage and slow. 5:B still not a bad pickup, just make sure you are waiting till enemies are low and then burst them. 5:C doesn't work here, don't bother.
T5:A damage increase works with Neuro and puddles, but not on hit corrosion DOT.
OC - Gamma contamination. Use with Wide lens and shot bursts across enemy units to get multiple Radiation procs and destroy entire groups.
Items:
Full damage satchels to take out problematic units like Warden, groups of Praetorian or Patrol bots.
Barbed drills don't give you a lot on this build, but can be used if desired, will always help with Shredders.
Grenades - Neuro grenades stack with all your other slows, including the neuro on the Colette gun (the two neuro are unique and will completely stack, damage and slow) you can reduce any enemy to a crawl or entire stop.
Axes are a good pickup as well, particularly on Robot missions or Exterminations.
Ripper - 145 EXPLOSIVE non radial damage. This grenade can't hit WP's, won't deal extra damage to frozen enemies and is very bad vs oppressors. It has poor Aoe, bad single target damage, does 112 Friendly fire damage. Only good for memeing on ally dwarves, or safety tunnels.
RANT
Hardened drills do NOT waste ammo. They do break terrain faster then your walking speed while using drills. If you pause every 7~ breaks and run forward, you can continue drilling without issue. They do still give you a speed boost, albeit more minor then the numbers would indicate.
There are also ways you can get around this. Ledge grab while drilling up, you can start drilling mid animation, and you won't be using walking speed.
Drilling at down angles can also give you increased move speed